Hello dear
Welcome To Michelangelo Pizzeria - Mattituck
Michelangelo Pizzeria - Mattituck is a standout gem located at 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY. Renowned for its friendly staff and exceptional food, this charming pizzeria offers a vast array of menu options, from delectable salads to a variety of pizza slices. Diners appreciate the excellent service and the inviting ambiance that feels both cozy and upscale. Reviews highlight the teamwork of the staff, especially during busy evenings, creating a delightful dining experience. Don't miss the affogato, a crowd favorite, making each visit a true culinary pleasure. With reasonable prices, Michelangelo's guarantees satisfaction for every palate.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Michelangelo Pizzeria - Mattituck
Welcome to Michelangelo Pizzeria - Mattituck, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Mattituck, New York. Located at 10095 Main Rd, this charming pizzeria brings a delightful slice of Italy to the North Fork of Long Island. With a phone number to reach them at +1 631-298-4100, they welcome both locals and visitors alike to indulge in a culinary experience that has everyone raving.
One of the standout features of Michelangelo Pizzeria is its friendly and attentive staff. Customers like Jason Yeager have praised the team for their warm service and delicious offerings at reasonable prices. The atmosphere here strikes a perfect balance between cozy and lively, with a lovely dining room complemented by a bar area, making it feel both intimate and vibrant, as noted by Fran Louis.
The menu is a treasure trove of options, perfect for pizza lovers and salad aficionados alike. Rich W couldn't have said it better; with a plethora of slice varieties and tasty menu items, there’s something to tickle every palate. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a meal, the teamwork demonstrated by the staff, even during busy evenings, ensures that service remains prompt and efficient.
But the true magic lies in the food. Many, including Tyler Havel, have acclaimed the pizza as some of the best on the island. The crust is perfectly baked, creating a delightful contrast with fresh toppings that burst with flavor. Plus, the side offerings such as their expertly crafted salads add a refreshing touch to your meal. And don't forget to save room for dessert — Trish Treacy mentioned that the affogato is an absolute must-try, truly a sweet ending to an unforgettable dining experience.
In summary, Michelangelo Pizzeria - Mattituck stands out not just for its exceptional food but also for its unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. Every bite tells a story, and every visit feels like being embraced by the warm culture of Italy. If you're in the Mattituck area, make it a point to visit this delightful pizzeria; your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Friendly staff, delicious food, and reasonable prices. ”
“ If you are in the Mattituck area, don't miss this. Great salads, umpteen choices of slices and / or menu items. Excellent service and,It is a joy to see the staff taking and filling the orders on a busy evening. GREAT TEAM WORK. We love it. ”
“ Excellent food & service! They have a lovely dining room & bar behind a store front pizzeria! Great find! ”
“ Felt like a big, fancy restaurant even though it’s small! Excellent food and service. Plus, the affogato was to die for! ”
“ Some of the best pizza I've had on the island. Service was quick even though they were busy. Polite staff ”
“ Stumbled across this spot when going to the Dr next door. Pizza is fantastic here! Dough is soft and chewy, sauce is tasty and cheese is delicious. The garlic knots are 10/10. Speciality slices certainly stand out here. Thanks Carlo! ”
“ Excellent service. I really appreciated the speedy response... ”
“ Excellent service with a smile! The best pizza I've tried anywhere, on the north or south fork of long island by far!!! The plain slice is amazing...the sicilian slice was even better! ”